Discussion:
Ranking of movies!
(too old to reply)
Echoes
2005-03-17 08:32:33 UTC
Permalink
Alright fellas, I know you guys have done this a million times. But
I'm a huge matrix fan and here are my ranking of the best to worst
matrix films. Like Empire Strikes Back, Reloaded is my top pick

1. Matrix:Reloaded.
2. The Matrix
3. Matrix:Revolutions

What are your guys order? I know no one would have Revolutions on top,
But Reloaded's Smith/Neo fight and traffic scenes make it my first
pick. Let me know which is up top picks and explain why. Thanks.
Gavin Smith
2005-03-17 08:48:59 UTC
Permalink
Arrogantly twisting the sterile canvas snoot of a fully charged icing
Post by Echoes
Alright fellas, I know you guys have done this a million times. But
I'm a huge matrix fan and here are my ranking of the best to worst
matrix films. Like Empire Strikes Back, Reloaded is my top pick
1. Matrix:Reloaded.
2. The Matrix
3. Matrix:Revolutions
What are your guys order?
The same as yours: Reloaded/Matrix/Revolutions.
Post by Echoes
I know no one would have Revolutions on top,
But Reloaded's Smith/Neo fight and traffic scenes make it my first
pick. Let me know which is up top picks and explain why.
Reloaded surprised me with how widely it expanded it's philosophical and
mythical references. That expansion was what hooked me in to the extent
that I am. That edges it just ahead of M1. Revolutions is last because
the siege is overlong and I would have liked for some of that time to be
spent showing us what Smith was up to in the Matrix.
Post by Echoes
Thanks.
You're welcome.
--
Gavin Smith
new e-mail:
gavin at slipgate hyphen adsl dot demon dot co dot uk
--
JPM III
2005-03-22 03:00:34 UTC
Permalink
Well since Reloaded and Revolutions are two parts of the same movie, this is
easy:

T1. Reloaded + Revolutions
T1. The Matrix
Post by Echoes
Alright fellas, I know you guys have done this a million times. But
I'm a huge matrix fan and here are my ranking of the best to worst
matrix films. Like Empire Strikes Back, Reloaded is my top pick
1. Matrix:Reloaded.
2. The Matrix
3. Matrix:Revolutions
What are your guys order? I know no one would have Revolutions on top,
But Reloaded's Smith/Neo fight and traffic scenes make it my first
pick. Let me know which is up top picks and explain why. Thanks.
JPM III
2005-03-22 03:01:41 UTC
Permalink
Post by Echoes
I know no one would have Revolutions on top
I missed that. If I had to divide them into a group of three, Revolutions
would be my favorite. So... there.
richard blezer
2005-03-22 19:52:04 UTC
Permalink
No way , Matrix first then the rest.

Revolutions and Reloaded just didn't surprise me, like the first movie did.
Amusing yes, curious how this would end yes, but thats it.
Post by JPM III
Post by Echoes
I know no one would have Revolutions on top
I missed that. If I had to divide them into a group of three, Revolutions
would be my favorite. So... there.
JPM III
2005-03-25 07:31:14 UTC
Permalink
I don't need surprises to be entertained. Reloaded/Revolutions looked
better, showed more, and introduced characters that I can't imagine the
Matrix story without. Some scenes were overdone, but that was true of the
first movie as well -- all art/cult films are like that to some degree.

But whatever, to each his own. The first movie was great for its innovation.
The second movie(s) were great for fleshing out an already incredible story
in ways that I couldn't have imagined, and not taking the typical hollywood
route.
Post by richard blezer
No way , Matrix first then the rest.
Revolutions and Reloaded just didn't surprise me, like the first
movie did. Amusing yes, curious how this would end yes, but thats it.
Post by JPM III
Post by Echoes
I know no one would have Revolutions on top
I missed that. If I had to divide them into a group of three,
Revolutions would be my favorite. So... there.
Loading...